Important Note:
Karen Dearlove and Ryan George are running another Undergraduate Writing Workshop for the winter term. This one will be next Monday, January 28th from 12:30 - 2:00 p.m. in ABB/164.

This page contains the information you need to know to successfully participate in Tutorials for 1BB3 Twentieth Century Global History - Winter 2008

Here you will find information on:

Also check out this blog and postings to it. This is not to up my own readership. I make a point of occasionally posting stories of aid to academic scholarship practise. If you search for ‘How To’s’, for example, you will find posts useful to learning at Mac or hints for being more successful in this course. So feel free to browse.

Contacting Me

  • Office Location: Chester New Hall 431
  • Office Hours: Monday 10:30-11am, Wednesday 9:30-10am
  • Email: shawnday at mcmaster dot ca.
  • Tutorial Hours: T19 - Monday 9:30-10:20am UH/B126G, T01 - Wednesday 8:30pm-9:20am TSH/B126

Handouts
Tutorial Handout

Schedule

  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney:Rosa Luxemburg, “The Junius Pamphlet” (8)
  • Vladimir Lenin, “Speech in Closing the 10th Congress of the Russian Communist Party” (42)
  • Nikita Khrushchev, “Khrushchev Remembers” (46)
  • Evgeniia Ginzburg, “Journey Into the Whirlwind” (51)
  • Novoe Vremya, “Russian Women in Combat” (82)
  • Woodrow Wilson, “Fourteen Points Speech” (88)
  • Henry Cabot Lodge, “On the League of Nations” (93)
  • J. M. Keynes, “The Economic Consequences of Peace” (91)

  1. Who are these people - quick identify and significance?
  2. What ties all these writings/speakings together?
  3. Were these people visionaries? - How accurate were their visions?
  4. Did the time at which they wrote temper their vision?
  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney: Heinrich Hauser, “With Germany’s Unemployed” (146)
  • George Orwell, “The Road to Wigan Pier” (149)
  • Paul Comly French, “Children on Strike” (159)
  • Alfredo Rocco, “The Weakness of the Liberal-Democratic State” (118)
  • Benito Mussolini, “Fascist Doctrines” (123)
  • Joseph Goebbels, “The Reich Ministry of Popular Enlightenment and
    Propaganda” (134)
  • Theodor Herzl, “The Jewish State” (4)
  • McMahon/Balfour, “The McMahon Letter/The Balfour Declaration” (99)
  • Government of Great Britain, “The British White Paper of 1939” (101)
  • Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry, “The Palestinian Arab Case”
    (266)
  • Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry, “Testimony by Chaim Weizmann”
    (270)
  • UN Security Council/Palestinian National Council, “Resolution
    242/Palestinian National Charter” (273)

First Assignment Due in Tutorial.
Consider the near fifty years of debate that went into the creation of Israel. Drawing from at least two relevant documents from the list below, discuss the longstanding tensions
associated with the creation and realization of the Israeli state. What role have international bodies played in the creation and maintenance of Israel?

Questions to Consider for this Week’s Readings:

  1. Who are these people authoring these selections - quick identify and significance?
  2. What common theme can you identify amongst these writings/speakings?
  3. Were these people visionaries? - How accurate were their visions?
  4. How did the time at which these were written influence perspective?
  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney:Armenian National Institute, “Press Reports on the Armenian Genocide” (85)
  • David Buffum, “On Kristallnacht” (140)
  • Margaret Freyer, “Eyewitness Account of the Firestorm in Dresden”
    (169)
  • Harold Timperley, “An Eyewitness Account at Nanjing” (171)
  • Muriel Kitagawa, “Letters to Wes” (177)
  • Victor Klemperer, “I Will Bear Witness” (183)
  • Bronia Spira, “The Berlin-Bucharest Express” (186)
  • Livia Bitton Jackson, “A Bowl of Soup” (188)
  • Stella Wiseltier, “Rejoining the Human Race” (192)
  • Gitta Sereny, “Into That Darkness” (194)
  • United Nations, “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights” (229)
  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney:Kwame Nkrumah, “Neo-Colonialism: The Last Stage of Imperialism” (343)
  • Frantz Fanon, “The Collaborating Class in Neo-Colonialism” (345)
  • Frantz Fanon, “The Wretched of the Earth” (291)
  • Julius Nyerere, “The Arusha Declaration” (348)
  • P.J. O’Rourke, “Inside Tanzania” (351)
  • The Atlantic Monthly, “Rwanda 1964” (355)
  • P.T. Bauer, “Western Guilt and Third World Poverty” (360)

Second Assignment Due in Tutorial.
Examine the optimism and pessimism surrounding African independence. Drawing on at least two of the documents below, assess the post-colonial relationship between Africa and the western world.

The Movie that I wanted to remember to recommend to you in tutorial is: Lumumba! It’s a 2000 French production. Extremely well done. Not a happy story, but one which help to demonstrate a spirit of the time - 1960s Congo. I highly recommend this movie, but warn that it does have some rather graphic violence.

  No Tutorials This Week
  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney: Winston Churchill, “Iron Curtain Speech” (209)
  • Joseph Stalin, “Response to Churchill, 14 March 1946” (213)
  • Alexandra Kollontai, “The Soviet Woman—A Full and Equal Citizen of
    Her Country” (220)
  • Milovan Djilas, “The New Class” (222)
  • Nikita Khrushchev, “Secret Speech” (225)
  • Roy R. Rubottom, Jr., “Communism in the Americas” (247)
  • Fidel Castro, “Havana Declaration” (258)

Third Assignment Due in Tutorial.
Compare and contrast Churchill’s “Iron Curtain Speech” with Stalin’s “Response to Churchill.” Discuss to what extent propaganda played a role in each excerpt and the nature of that propaganda with specific reference to their context.

  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney: Ito Hirobumi, “On the Constitution of 1889” (56)
  • Sun Yat-sen, “Fundamentals of National Reconstruction” (65)
  • Soong Ching-ling, “The Struggle for New China” (68)
  • Yang Chengwu, “The Luding Bridge” (71)
  • Mao Zedong, “The Foolish Old Man Who Removed the Mountains” (311)
  • Mao Zedong, “On Let a Hundred Flowers Blossom, Let a Hundred Schools
    of Thought Contend” (313)
  • Fox Butterfield, “Lihua” (317)
  • Chai Ling, “June Four: A Chronicle of the Chinese Democratic
    Uprising” (319)
  • Jiang Zemin, “China-US Relations” (322)
  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney: Eleanor Roosevelt, “Women Must Learn to Play the Game as Men Do” (367)
  • Simone de Beauvoir, “The Second Sex” (372)
  • Redstockings, “A Feminist Manifesto” (376)
  • Jean-Paul Sartre, “Existentialism” (377)
  Greene & Bowles Essay due in lecture, 20 March 2007
No tutorials this week
  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney: Vaclav Havel, “Disturbing the Peace” (394)
  • Lech Walesa, “A Way of Hope” (396)
  • Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, “Rebuilding Russia” (404).
  This weeks tutorial readings:

  • Kinney: Naomi Klein, “No Logo” (417)
  • Neil Mohindra, “Markets Should Be Free to Roam the World” (424)
  • Robert Kaplan, “World Government” (427)
  • Benjamin Barber, “Jihad vs. McWorld” (428)
  • Robert Kaplan, “Old Serbia and Albania” & “Moldova” (433)
  • Edward Said, “Protecting the Kosovars” (439)
  • Philip Gourevitch, “We Wish To Inform You That Tomorrow We Will Be
    Killed With Our Families” (441)

Tutorial FAQ

Not a question or an answer, but rather a warning:
The perils of writing with a thesaurus

Q: What format should I be using for essay citations?
A: As specified on the course outline, Dr. Egan expects you to use The Chicago Manual of StyleSee Casson 89-99. Additional formatting information is available in the library online at : Link to Turabian/Chicago Citing Guide at Mills Library

Q: Should the essay use footnotes or endnotes?
A: I prefer footnotes.

Q: Are Online Sources acceptable as essay sources?
A: This is a much more complex question than can be answered here. In the essay assignment you are required to cite the sources listed in the essay handout. These may be obtained online, however you have to ask yourself, are all online sources of the same veracity? The following tutorial will be of use in answering this question:
http://www.vts.intute.ac.uk/he/tutorial/history

Q: What do I do if I am going to be away and unable to attend tutorial?
A: Your first and preferred option is to attend the other tutorial that I hold.

Q: How many sources do I have to use in my essay?
A: The immediate answer to this is ‘as many as are necessary to adequately substantiate your argument.’ Of course this is not a hard and fast number, and in fact there isn’t one. Each topic is different and the available source base varies widely. The more current the source you use, the more you can expect that that source will refer to a wider body of additional materials.

Q: So what’s the deal with Wikipedia? Can and Should I use it as asourcse?
A: From Wikipedia itself comes the following: “Most educators and professionals do not consider it appropriate to use tertiary sources such as encyclopedias as a sole source for any information — citing an encyclopedia as an important reference in footnotes or bibliographies may result in censure or a failing grade. Wikipedia articles should be used for background information, as a reference for correct terminology and search terms, and as a starting point for further research.
As with any community-built reference, there is a possibility for error in Wikipedia’s content — please check your facts against multiple sources and read our disclaimers for more information. ”

shawnwide.jpg